DFN: In their own voices

   
 
 

From the halls of power to the labyrinths of incarceration: A letter from prison
by Anwar Ibrahim  

(Updated April 14, 1999) This letter from prison was written by Anwar Ibrahim, former deputy prime minister of Malaysia and heir apparent to Prime Minster Mahathir Mohamed. Anwar was arrested on September 30, 1998 on sex and corruption charges, three weeks after being fired by Mohathir. (The two had clashed on policy for months as the Malaysian economy struggled.) Anwar’s trial began in November. In April 1999, he was convicted on corruption charges and sentenced to six years in prison.

Malaysian reformers pictureIn a November 1998 letter from prison, excerpted below, Anwar makes harsh allegations against Mahathir. He calls the prime minister a “grumpy old man” and a “senile power-drunk tyrant” who uses the government and media to prop up his rule. Anwar accuses Mahathir of widespread corruption. While acknowledging his own ties to Mahathir’s government, Anwar says that he tried to speak out but was silenced because Mahathir “tolerates no dissent or criticism.”

Anwar isn’t the only Malaysian politician who to be jailed after outspoken criticism of the government. Opposition politician Lim Guan Eng was convicted of sedition in August after lambasting judiciary officials for not pressing charges against a government official who allegedly had sex with a 15-year-old girl, even though the girl confessed to having sex with the official.

 
 
 

Anwar picture

Latest on the Anwar case

DFN analysis: Malaysian reformers

I am now incarcerated at Sungai Buloh prison after being released from the clutches of Mahathir’s henchmen at Bukit Aman. Much as he wanted to, Mahathir could not keep me detained without trial indefinitely because of my habeas corpus application, which he had to avoid at all costs. The hearing of the application, if properly conducted, would have brought to light his role in the conspiracy against me. He just does not have the guts to face me in open court or anywhere else for that matter.

Mahathir is determined to keep me behind bars for at least four years. His original plan was to keep me incarcerated indefinitely under the draconian Internal Security Act (ISA), but the pressure against this has proven too great. My habeas corpus application, coupled with the international condemnation of the detention without trial, and the massive show of public support for me forced the tyrant’s hand. But still he would not take any chances. Hence, bail has been denied and I am still behind bars.

The tranquility of the prison environment is a far cry from the notorious police lock-up at Bukit Aman or, worse, solitary confinement under the Special Branch’s supervision. My whereabouts before this was unknown to me because I was moved about blindfolded and handcuffed.

Although I must acknowledge the general sympathy of policemen who did not hide their disdain of Mahathir and police top brass, the three weeks I spent under police custody was pure hell. I was humiliated, tortured, stripped, denied any reading and fed meagerly with food wrapped in old newspapers or plastic.

“Mahathir continues to rave like a grumpy, recalcitrant old man.”

Throughout the three weeks of ISA detention, the total time taken in serious interrogation was less than two hours. There were questions relating to Reformasi and suggestions that I should have been patient a while longer until I became prime minister before trying to initiate changes. I discussed corruption, abuse of power and the amassing of wealth by Mahathir and his close associates for their families and cronies. I told them to note Attorney General Mohtar Abdullah’s enthusiasm in pursuing a technical corruption case against me. Obviously, he is acting under Mahathir’s instruction and has chosen to be blind to the fact that Mahathir and his cronies have siphoned off billions. Mohtar cannot plead ignorance to this; he had, on a number of occasions, discussed with me this very crime involving Mahathir, Daim Zainuddin, Rahim Tamby Chik and some ministers.

Naturally, I think of Azizah [Anwar’s wife] and the family, especially my ailing mother. And now Azizah and my daughter, Nurul Izzah, are being threatened with arrest. The ISA is being invoked to protect Mahathir and his cronies. Popular dissent and criticism of rampant corruption and abuse of power are construed as anti-national and a threat to national security. No one is spared the threat of harassment, interrogation or arrest — UMNO and opposition leaders, NGOs, Muslim activists, my personal staff and particularly supporters of Reformasi. There is a nationwide crackdown against all known supporters of reform. It is a final desperate attempt by a despised dictator to cling to power. Instead of trying to win popular and legitimate support, he is instituting a culture of fear.

The public is outraged over the continued repressive acts of the government to stifle dissent. There is a deliberate attempt to provoke peaceful demonstrators, who are portrayed as a mob trying to frustrate the functioning of a purportedly legitimate, democratic government. Every violent incident so far has been started by the police. And the arrests continue — ISA for the leaders and the Police Act and whatever other laws they can use for their supporters.

Mahathir continues to rave like a grumpy, recalcitrant old man. He has become increasingly contemptible as he gives vent to his anger, venom and egoism. His intransigence is due to his blinkered and intractably condescending view of the general public as ignorant and indolent.  

Superman

Before my sacking, colleagues had advised me to exercise restraint and patience, to continue to support Mahathir in order not to jeopardize my political career. During my detention at the police lock-up, curious Special Branch officers asked what went wrong with my relationship with Mahathir. I admit that initially the relationship was cordial and comfortable. But in the last few years, egged on by his children and close political and business associates, he had become increasingly dictatorial and tyrannical, wanting a formidable historical imprint of his legacy. Since he tolerates no dissent or criticism whatsoever, he spews his venom on NGOs and the media. He uses the police, the attorney general and the judiciary to ensure his invincibility. Indeed, having out-maneuvered virtually every challenge, he thinks of himself as Superman and a maestro at the divide-and-rule strategy vis-à-vis the party, the country, and international relations.

Driven by a self-induced frenzy to pursue his megalomaniacal fantasies, he became increasingly divorced from the real world. He could not differentiate the wants and needs of the people from his own egotistical desires. In the last few years, he has become increasingly isolated as he got impatient to get things done so that they would serve as monuments to his majestic rule. Surrounded by sycophantic courtiers, he failed to realize that his ideas were getting obsolete and irrelevant.

As a high-ranking member of the administration, I often had to articulate and implement key policies. And when these were policies that I was personally unhappy with, I did so with great reluctance. But I took every opportunity to emphasize poverty eradication, low-cost housing, rural development, and small and medium-scale industries instead of mega projects. And whenever the opportunity to be bold presented itself, I criticized bailouts and the avarice of big tycoons and I called for greater commitment to democratic practices and the development of civil society. I even openly opposed Mahathir’s attempt to initiate a no-contest rule in UMNO divisional elections, which was his way of pre-empting a possible challenge for the presidency.  

Lim picture
 

Malaysian Dream from Kajang Prison (December 8, 1998)

“One Month in Kajang Prison” by Betty Chew, Lim’s wife (September 27, 1998)

“I Am Still Free!”, poem written from prison by Lim (August 26, 1998)

Letter from prison by Lim (April 1, 1998)

Lim Guan Eng

The local media has played its role as scandal-mongerer to the hilt in this case, insulting the intelligence of their subscribers in the process. They have even questioned the propriety of my support of Lim Guan Eng, another obvious victim of yet another Mahathir-engineered conspiracy. My stand on the Guan Eng case was clear even before I was sacked. Asked by a Malaysian student in London to comment on it, I said the government may need to study and undertake reforms of the country’s law which punishes a person who exposes alleged wrongdoings but takes no action against the person accused of such wrongdoings. Any right-thinking person would find difficulty in reconciling in his mind the fact that someone championing the cause of a rape victim is in jail, while the rapist goes off scot-free. And now this criminal has been hand-picked by Mahathir to be among his chief spokesmen, to tell the public that I am “morally unfit” to become prime minister.  

Reformasi Begins

I am touched by the support of family, friends and others who believe in me and the struggle for reform. It is indeed gratifying to see that in spite of the use of the formidable state apparatus to assassinate my character, the support gets bigger and more vociferous with every new attempt by the Mahathir forces to justify my persecution.

I must thank my loyal friends in UMNO, including party chiefs — except those in high positions — who have voiced support for me in spite of threats by Mahathir’s office and the police. The Special Branch has indeed become the Party President’s personal tool for stifling dissent. I acknowledge too the role of NGOs, Muslim scholars, religious groups, professionals and, particularly, people in the middle and low income groups in making the Reformasi movement a force that must be reckoned with.

I knew there would be support for me, but I certainly did not expect it to be so overwhelming in terms of both numbers of people and intensity of feeling. Every strata of society and all age groups are represented in this people’s movement to press for reform, although the most visible are youths from both urban and rural areas. Malaysia is undergoing a radical change, and I am confident that it is for the better. The people can no longer stomach unjust policies and practices; they want the freedom to speak and their rightful say in the running of the country. The tide is irreversible.  

Mahathir Desperate

It was gratifying to see Malaysians of all racial and social backgrounds rallying to the call for reform. Although the government-controlled media downplayed, completely ignored or tried to discredit the gatherings at my house, the crowds grew larger by the day and shouts of “Reformasi” and “Mahathir resign” grew louder. Finally, after a week, I had to accede to requests for a “road show” for the benefit of supporters who could not make the trip to Kuala Lumpur to listen to speeches by Reformasi leaders. On September 12, in my own parliamentary constituency, Permatang Pauh, I read a declaration launching a movement for comprehensive reform. In it, we stress the need to preserve the institutions and processes of law from graft and abuse of power, to promote economic justice and to restore power and fundamental liberties to the people. We also reiterate that we do not condone violence and call on the powers that be to respect the rule of law.

The push for reform must continue. Why should the people continue to be beaten up by the police, or locked up for exercising their constitutional right to assemble and express their loathing of the Mahathir regime? Are the people expected to continue indefinitely to endure the ranting and raving of a senile, power-drunk tyrant? Long live Reformasi.


Sg Buloh Prison
3 November 1998

     
     
 

RELATED MATERIAL

MALAYSIA: RELATED MATERIAL

 
 
 
 

Home | Take a stand | Volunteer | Subscribe
News | Online chats | Related links | Download | Activist's workshop
About us | Media kit | Our positions | Contact us | Site map

Unless otherwise noted, all material copyright © 2002 Digital Freedom Network.

 
HOME

ACT
Take a stand
Volunteer
Subscribe

LEARN
News
Online chats
Related links

TECH
Download
Activist's workshop

ABOUT
About us
Media kit
Our positions
Contact us
Site map